The League of Extraordinary Authorities...
Anyone with an interest in adoption will have seen and heard the
Government's announcements about the reforms of the adoption system. Local
Authority league tables for adoption were released a few days ago.
Obviously I had a sneaky peak at the stats for our LA and saw how many children were waiting to be adopted. I then wondered how I should digest this information. Yes, there are "x" amount of children in our LA approved for adoption but what does that table tell me about these children? Does it tell me how many sibling groups there are? How old those children are? What their needs are? No. It just gives me a number. What help is that in reality for would-be adopters coming into the adoption system? You could look at a high number and you might think that your LA is failing. What you don't know is how many hard to place children might be included in those figures. You can say anything with numbers and statistics. The real information is in the detail, which isn't given in these numbers. If I'm honest I think prospective adopters need to be asking their agencies or Local Authorities more informed questions about this information. How under-staffed are they at the current time (or how many vacancies for social workers are there currently?) What is their expected time to process your application? What sort of adopters are they looking to recruit? What sort of children are they looking to place?
Obviously I had a sneaky peak at the stats for our LA and saw how many children were waiting to be adopted. I then wondered how I should digest this information. Yes, there are "x" amount of children in our LA approved for adoption but what does that table tell me about these children? Does it tell me how many sibling groups there are? How old those children are? What their needs are? No. It just gives me a number. What help is that in reality for would-be adopters coming into the adoption system? You could look at a high number and you might think that your LA is failing. What you don't know is how many hard to place children might be included in those figures. You can say anything with numbers and statistics. The real information is in the detail, which isn't given in these numbers. If I'm honest I think prospective adopters need to be asking their agencies or Local Authorities more informed questions about this information. How under-staffed are they at the current time (or how many vacancies for social workers are there currently?) What is their expected time to process your application? What sort of adopters are they looking to recruit? What sort of children are they looking to place?
In an article in The Telegraph on 16th
January 2013 Andrew Webb, Vice President of the
Association of Directors of Children’s Services (ADCS) said: “It is a
crude measure and whilst we understand the rationale for this map, it is not a
proportionate analysis and cannot be used to judge “good” or “bad” authorities.
BASW’s Acting Chief Executive Bridget Robb, in a statement issued on the BASW website,
said “So yes, it is welcome to help signpost potential adopters to
services that could help them to eventually take a child into their lives, but
talk of 'hotspots', areas where children are spending the longest time 'waiting
for new homes' is yet another example of this government's simplistic approach
to an incredibly complex subject.”
I'm tempted to agree with these statements.
If I'm honest I have concerns that this roadmap might leave prospective
adopters feeling confused, lost and needing directions.
Well one
port of call (so to speak) in the confusion is the new helpline that has been
launched to help support and advise prospective adopters (see statement by Adoption UK).
The hotline, which is funded by the Department for Education and operated by
Coram; Adoption UK and Coram Children's Legal
Centre, is called First4Adoption. Hugh Thornbery, Adoption UK
Chief Executive, said: “This service aims to be a comprehensive, supportive
resource to anyone who is thinking of adopting. Our advisors, all of whom are
adoptive parents, will be on hand to answer questions relating to the adoption
process. “We encourage anyone who has an interest in adoption and who
wants to find out more about becoming an adoptive parent to get in touch by
calling 0300 222 0022.”
At the moment the website isn't fully functional and it is planned
to launch this in the Spring of this year (2013). I hope that this helpline
will be successful but I do question why it was needed when you already have
the BAAF and Adoption UK offering information and advice on their telephone
lines. Maybe one centralised line is the answer (although I hope this
isn't a gimmick) and that funding is fully committed by the government for the
foreseeable future.
Also related to the current reforms of the adoption system are
plans to offer more support to adopters once they are approved in the form of
Adoption Activity Days. These days are being piloted by the BAAF and
offer children and prospective adopters a chance to meet and make
connections. I don't feel that I have enough background information to
comment properly on this activity. Success stories are documented, and
this is wonderful for the families it creates, but I do have a concern about
the impact on the children who remain unchosen as a result of these days and
hope that children are carefully selected to participate in order to ensure
that children do not feel further rejected. Also included in the reforms
are plans to bring adoption leave in line with that of current maternity and
paternity legislation; giving adoptive parents the right to take paid time off
work during introductions with their child/ren; a trial of personal budgets
(which I need to hear more about before I can comment on); the extension of free early education for
two year-olds to adopted children from 2014 and giving them priority school
access from 2013. More details can be found on the Department for Education's website.
I am
delighted to see Adoption at the forefront of government reforms but my ongoing
concern still remains unresolved - just how much funding is being put into
these initiatives to support the Local Authorities and other agencies involved
in adoption? With the current cuts to public funding councils are making
cuts to staff, not recruiting. I can see the impact of this on my own
Local Authority and it doesn't take a genius to question what the impact on
Social Workers to all the added pressure will be without additional staff to
support these reforms. How many more Social Workers will be needing sick
leave because of stress? This isn't just effecting adoption but all areas
of social care. I don't want to be a cynic. It's actually not my nature
to be that way but I've been around the adoption (and social care) block for
far too long to assimilate all these reforms without mentioning the obvious
word.........FUNDING!
What are
your thoughts and experiences? Do share them with me.
I wonder if the reforms will just be a cost-cutting exercise. Less to pay to fosterers and less to pay for adoption services.
ReplyDeleteOutsourced adoption services could end up as a box-ticking process to keep up with quotas like the Atos Healthcare disability assessments.